Home    Subscribe    Write for Us    FAQ    Contact    HubGarden    Login

Is it appropriate for an author to review another author's work?

by Jennifer Muirhead (follow)
I am learning all the time. The tombstone will be my diploma ~ Eartha Kitt.
Question (197)      Ethics (4)     

typing, author
Image from Morguefile.

Fantasy author Jim C. Hines raised this question on his blog recently and it got me thinking about it. In particular, is it appropriate for an author to share a negative review of another author's work? Is there a conflict of interest? What do you think?

I like this Question - 7
[ Submit an Answer ]
Top Answers
This question is of particular interest to me because I am a published author and a reviewer. I've only had a few short stories published, so I'm not the sort of author Hines is talking about (ie. somebody who actually makes a living out of it) but I'd like to be one day so I'm curious about other people's thoughts on this topic.

I agree with Hines that there would certain practical problems for the author, like angering publishers, but ethically I think it's okay. It's just the author's opinion of someone else's work. I know some people think you should just refrain from reviewing books you really hate, and a negative review is might be less useful to reader than a recommendation, but I can understand wanting to let rip if a really awful book upset you or made you angry.
I think that as long as you are open about the fact that you are an author (obviously if you're famous this will apparent!) and are therefore critiquing your "competition" then it would be fine to review another author's work. I do think that if you are offering a negative review of someone who is your competition then you will be called upon to provide VERY robust reasoning and it could put other people off your work if they are left wondering if you are simply being vindictive.

I guess I don't see an ethical issue but you'd probably want to tread carefully!
I don't think so... maybe

I think it's a brave man (or woman) that does, but many do.In paul Theroux's Hotel Honolulu, he takes a swipe at Stephen King - I don't know if they're friends, or enemies. It's a little weird tho....
Why not? Is there some 'publishing' rule which states one cannot!

IMO, if the reviewer is qualified to do so, why not?
Or does 'rivalry' come into it, as well as 'jealousy'?
Is it a 'closed shop' scenario?

I know nothing about publishing, so I'm just 'stabbing in the dark' here!
More Articles by Jennifer Muirhead
view all articles by Jennifer Muirhead
Articles by Jennifer Muirhead on Other Hubs
ID: 36719
Trending Articles
Fiction (373)
Question (197)
Writing (22)
Comics (47)
Poetry (16)
Essay (8)
Humour (83)
Fantasy (68)
Romance (25)
Lesbian (15)
LGBT (13)
Zombies (11)
Sex (2)
Gay (2)
Food (2)
Myth (1)
Action (1)
Copyright 2012-2021 OatLabs ABN 18113479226. mobile version